A new Bill from the Government (the ‘NHS Modernisation Bill’) proposes significant changes to how people’s voices are heard in health and social care.
These changes are subject to Parliamentary scrutiny and may be amended before becoming law.
Under the Bill, Healthwatch England’s functions would transfer to the Department of Health and Social Care. It also proposes that the statutory arrangements for Local Healthwatch would end, with some functions potentially delivered through Integrated Care Boards and local authorities.
For the first time in decades, this all could mean the absence of any and all independent opportunities for the public to influence standards of health and social care in England.
The Bill will go through Parliament and may be subject to amendment before any changes are finalised.
Read a blog from our Independent Chair (Wendy Herber)
“This is not a time for guessing”.
Healthwatch & why independence matters
For more than a decade, local Healthwatch have been the independent voice making sure people’s experiences shape health and care. The statutory status and independence of the service means it can challenge poor practice, recognise best practice in health and care provision, conduct impartial research, and ensure people’s voices are heard without fear or favour.
When local health and social care systems struggle, and when services are under pressure, it is Healthwatch that has carried people’s experiences and views into rooms and forums that may not want to hear them. Our service brings them anyway, and leaders listen and respond.
The Kings Fund has warned that any future model must protect—not weaken—independent scrutiny, stating that services must be able to “speak truth to power and raise difficult messages where necessary”.
Healthwatch was created after the Mid Staffordshire scandal, where the absence of independent challenge contributed to serious harm. There is a very real concern that removing or diluting independence risks repeating those mistakes and significantly weakens public accountability.
- Independence matters because it’s hard to be honest when someone holds your care or funding in their hands: The freedom to listen requires independence of the system. People need distance to give feedback with honesty, and without fear, consequence, or judgment.
- Independence matters because we need to hear from everyone to create meaningful change: Healthwatch gathers feedback from everyone, utilising relationships and partnerships to reach people who would not have a voice otherwise. This independent connectivity into communities that will be immediately lost if these plans remain unchanged.
- Independence matters because services are siloed, lives are not: The NHS and social care system is intimidatingly huge and too-often works against the most vulnerable people. Without an independent organisation that works across systems, we cannot understand the gaps in provision that lead people to fall into crisis.
More than a decade of impact and influence – how Healthwatch makes a difference locally
Your feedback helps our Healthwatch service to raise important issues with local leaders and improve services.
Feedback in recent years has meant:
- People’s experiences are leading to action by local NHS leaders to protect people from mental and physical harm while they wait for elective care. In addition, a system action plan was created to respond to our research, leading to reviews of how people are supported when they are living in pain and how people are supported to stay well.
- GP practices have been able to make many important changes that we know have improved patients’ experiences over the years. Our visits to services help them to monitor people’s experiences and to make improvements (from new appointment systems, to improving physical environments, and making practical changes to how services operate).
- Services for vulnerable people, such as people living with an acquired brain injury, were not lost.
- People’s views and experiences were included in countless critical strategies that have shaped how local services are planned and delivered.
- Support for dementia in Suffolk was shaped by people’s experiences and what local families needed. Furthermore, our research is helping to inspire new projects and initiatives that aim to improve support for people living with this terrible illness.
- We encouraged a ‘Digital first, but not digital only’ approach that has tackled digital exclusion in service design.
- Maternity services were able to address negative feedback and improve people’s experiences overall, including by helping staff to respond to people in much more compassionate ways. Feedback recently improved patient safety after establishing a clinic that will increase continuity of care for mums-to-be on the boundaries of hospital catchments.
- We helped services reflect on people’s needs at the end of life, driving changes in how palliative care has been delivered locally.
- Our challenge led to the funding of a Restricted Lingual Frenulum (RLF) clinic that has, over a period of several years now, helped hundreds of local parents who had struggled with infant feeding. The clinic is for the treatment of newborns with tongue tie.
- Many services have improved how they provide accessible information and support for those living with a disability or sensory impairment.
These examples represent only a fraction of how more than 200,000 local experiences have shaped better care over 12 years. In addition, our local Healthwatch has:
- Connected people and services together to provide support at grass roots. For example, linking contacts in groups and organisations to encourage new partnerships and to support individuals in communities.
- Signposted thousands of people to information, services, and support with known positive outcomes across all years of the Healthwatch service.
- Helped decision-makers to take innovative approaches to public engagement and co-production – ensuring communities have a genuine say in the shape of their future services and systems.
What do you think?
We think protecting independence in public health and care involvement really matters – and we hope you do too.
If you do, you might consider contact with your local MP and other influential public figures.
